Camera-ready paper format for Triple Blind Submission and Review
Your final papers MUST be formatted to IEEE Computer Society Proceedings Manuscript Formatting Guidelines. It is highly recommended that you proofread and check the layout of your paper BEFORE submitting it to PDF eXpress.
Formatting Instructions for double blind submission
Formatting Instructions for camera-ready submission
LaTeX and Word document templates
Triple blind submission guidelines
Since 2011, ICDM will impose a triple blind submission and review policy for all submissions. Authors must hence not use identifying information in the text of the paper and bibliographies must be referenced to preserve anonymity. The following sections give further information for authors.
What is triple blind reviewing?
The traditional blind paper submission hides the referee name from the authors. The triple-blind paper submission and review, in addition, also hides the authors names from the referees, and the referees' names during discussion. The names of authors and referees remain known only to the PC co-chairs, and the authors names are disclosed only after the ranking and acceptance of submissions are finalized. Although there is much debate on the merits and perceived benefits of triple blind reviewing, these are not discussed here. Our main purpose is to implement this policy in ICDM toward understanding the influence of the authors' identity, whether conscious or unconscious, on the reviewer's attitude toward a submission. Hence it is imperative that all authors of ICDM submissions work on concealing their identity in the content of the paper. It does not suffice to simply remove the authors' names from the first page.
How to prepare your submissions
- The authors shall omit their names from the submission.
- In the submission, the authors' should refer to their own prior work like the prior work of any other author, and include all relevant citations. This can be done either by referring to their prior work in the third person or referencing papers generically. For example, if your name is Smith and you have worked on clustering, instead of saying "We extend our earlier work on distance-based clustering (Smith 2005)," you might say "We extend Smith's (Smith 2005) earlier work on distance-based clustering."
- The authors shall exclude citations to their own work which is not fundamental to understanding the paper, including prior versions (e.g., technical reports, unpublished internal documents) of the submitted paper. They should reference only necessary work using point (2). Hence, do not write: "In our previous work " as it reveals that citation 3 is written by the current authors.
- The authors shall remove mention of funding sources, personal acknowledgments, and other such auxiliary information that could be related to their identities. These can be reinstituted in the camera-ready copy once the paper is accepted for publication.
- The authors shall make statements on well-known or unique systems that identify an author, as vague in respect to identifying the authors as possible.
- The submitted files shall be named with care to ensure that authors' anonymity is not compromised by the file name. E.g., do not name your submission "< YourFirstName>.pdf", instead give it a name that is descriptive of the title of your paper, such as "ANewApproachtoClustering.pdf" (or a shorter version of the same).
Banner image courtesy of Tourism Vancouver. All website related inquires should be directed to firstname.lastname@example.org.